No Evil Foods Comrade Cluck: Discontinued — the Best Plant-Based Chicken to Buy Instead
What happened to Comrade Cluck?
No Evil Foods, the North Carolina company behind Comrade Cluck “No Chicken”, stopped production and closed its business. Comrade Cluck is no longer made, and any Amazon listing still carrying the name shows as unavailable. If you have searched for it recently, that is why you can’t find it in stock.
We have kept this page up because plenty of people still search for Comrade Cluck by name. Rather than send you to a dead listing, the rest of this page covers what the product was, which plant-based chicken products you can actually buy today, and how to pick the right one for the way you used it.
What made Comrade Cluck popular
From No Evil Foods’ own product information, Comrade Cluck was:
- Wheat-protein based — a seitan-style product, so it had a dense, fibrous, pull-apart texture rather than a soft, crumbly one.
- Lightly seasoned — neutral enough to take on a marinade or sauce.
- Sold refrigerated and ready to cook — no rehydrating, just slice or shred and heat.
- Versatile — it was used anywhere you would use shredded or chopped chicken: sandwiches, wraps, tacos, stir-fries, curries, salads and BBQ.
So when you look for a replacement, the questions are: do you want the same texture (shreddable, chewy), the same convenience (ready to eat), or something that keeps in the pantry so you never run out? The picks below cover each of those.
At-a-glance comparison
| Pick | Brand | Format | Key spec (from the listing) | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best Overall | Butler | Dried, shelf-stable | Whole soybean, vegan, gluten-free | Amazon →$24.49Price as of Oct 19, 2026, 14:03 UTC |
| Best Ready-to-Eat | unMEAT | Canned, shelf-stable | Fully cooked chicken-style chunks | Amazon →$31.95Price as of Oct 19, 2026, 14:03 UTC |
| Best High-Protein Mix | Creative Pea | Dry mix, shelf-stable | Pea protein, 20g protein per serving | Amazon →$19.95Price as of Oct 19, 2026, 14:03 UTC |
| Best Bulk Buy | Plant Basics | Dried chunks, 6 lb bag | Unflavored, 14g protein per serving | Amazon →$59.99Price as of Oct 19, 2026, 14:03 UTC |
| Closest to Comrade Cluck’s base | Upton’s Naturals | Refrigerated seitan | Wheat-protein seitan, vegan | Amazon →$4.58Price as of Oct 19, 2026, 14:03 UTC |
Top picks
Best Overall — Butler Soy Curls, 8 oz Bags (Pack of 3)
Why this pick: It keeps in the pantry, it is made from one whole-food ingredient, and once rehydrated it shreds into chicken-style strips you can use in the same dishes Comrade Cluck went into.
Key specifications, from the Amazon listing:
- Made from the whole soybean
- Vegan, gluten-free, non-GMO
- Dried format — rehydrate in warm water or broth, then cook
- Three 8 oz bags (also sold as single bags and larger packs)
If you cooked Comrade Cluck into stir-fries, tacos or BBQ sandwiches, this is the most flexible pantry swap here. Note that it is soy-based rather than wheat-based, so it suits gluten-free cooks but not anyone avoiding soy.
Check Butler Soy Curls Price on Amazon →$24.49Price as of Oct 19, 2026, 14:03 UTC
Best Ready-to-Eat — unMEAT Plant-Based Vegan Chicken Style Chunks, 6.3 oz (6 Pack)
Why this pick: It is the closest match to Comrade Cluck’s open-and-use convenience, without needing fridge space until you open it.
Key specifications, from the Amazon listing:
- 100% plant-based chicken-style chunks, fully cooked and ready to eat from the can
- Shelf-stable until opened
- Non-GMO ingredients, no artificial flavors or preservatives, zero cholesterol
- Listed uses: salads, sandwiches, quesadillas, wraps, rice dishes and stir-fries
- Six 6.3 oz cans
Good for quick lunches and meal prep where you would otherwise have reached for a pack of Comrade Cluck.
Check unMEAT Price on Amazon →$31.95Price as of Oct 19, 2026, 14:03 UTC
Best High-Protein Mix — Creative Pea Chicken Free Plant-Based Meat Substitute (227 g)
Why this pick: A dry, shelf-stable pea-protein mix with a high listed protein figure — useful if you used Comrade Cluck mainly as a protein base.
Key specifications, from the Amazon listing:
- Pea-protein, chicken-style dry mix; add water and oil
- 20g protein per serving (per the listing)
- Gluten-free
- Makes about 2 lb once prepared
- Listed as ready in about 5 minutes; no refrigeration needed before preparing
It cooks into a chicken-style mince rather than strips, so it suits wraps, curries, soups and stir-fries more than sandwiches. Being gluten-free and pea-based, it is also an option for people who avoid both wheat and soy — check the full ingredient list on the listing for your own allergens.
Check Creative Pea Price on Amazon →$19.95Price as of Oct 19, 2026, 14:03 UTC
Best Bulk Buy — Plant Basics Hearty Plant Protein, Unflavored Chunks (6 lb Bulk Bag)
Why this pick: If you went through Comrade Cluck every week, a large bag of dried chunks is the most practical way to keep a plant-based “chicken” on hand.
Key specifications, from the Amazon listing:
- Unflavored dried chunks — season or marinate them yourself
- 14g plant protein per serving (per the listing)
- Non-GMO, gluten-free, low fat, low sodium, cholesterol-free, kosher
- Prepared by boiling in broth or water
- 6 lb bulk bag
Because the chunks are unflavored, they take on whatever you cook them in — the same reason a lightly seasoned product like Comrade Cluck worked across so many recipes.
Check Plant Basics Price on Amazon →$59.99Price as of Oct 19, 2026, 14:03 UTC
Closest to Comrade Cluck’s Base — Upton’s Naturals Traditional Seitan, 8 oz
Why this pick: Comrade Cluck was wheat-protein based. Seitan is wheat protein too, so this is the nearest match on base ingredient in our list.
Key specifications, from the Amazon listing:
- Traditional (lightly seasoned) seitan
- Vegan, Non-GMO Project Verified
- Listed as a good source of protein, low in carbs and fat
- 8 oz pack, sold refrigerated
This is a perishable, chilled product, so stock on Amazon moves around more than the pantry picks above. Not suitable for anyone avoiding gluten.
Check Upton's Naturals Price on Amazon →$4.58Price as of Oct 19, 2026, 14:03 UTC
Honourable mentions
Gardein Plant-Based Seven Grain Crispy Tenders (9 oz)
From Gardein. A frozen, breaded plant-based chick’n tender (breaded with oats, quinoa and millet), certified vegan and Non-GMO Project Verified per the listing. Worth a look if you want ready-made “chicken” tenders rather than plain pieces. Check on Amazon →$6.39Price as of Oct 19, 2026, 14:03 UTC
How to choose a Comrade Cluck replacement
1. Decide what you miss most. If it was the shreddable texture, start with Butler Soy Curls or Upton’s seitan. If it was “open the pack and cook”, go for unMEAT. If it was mostly a protein base for bowls and wraps, look at Creative Pea or Plant Basics.
2. Pantry or fridge? Dried (Butler, Creative Pea, Plant Basics) and canned (unMEAT) products keep in the cupboard and ship easily. Refrigerated and frozen products (Upton’s, Gardein) need cold storage and tend to sell out faster on Amazon.
3. Check the protein base against your allergens. Comrade Cluck was wheat-based. Here, Upton’s seitan is wheat; Butler Soy Curls are soy; Creative Pea is pea protein. Always read the full ingredient and allergen statement on the current Amazon listing before you buy — formulations change.
4. Seasoned or plain? Plain products (Butler, Plant Basics) need a marinade, broth or sauce to taste of anything — which also means they fit any cuisine. Pre-seasoned products save time but limit where you can use them.
5. Compare price per serving, not per pack. Pack sizes range from a single 8 oz pack to a 6 lb bag. The live Amazon price is shown next to each button above with the time it was checked.
6. Label nutrition. Sodium and saturated fat vary widely across processed plant-based meats. Per the EAT-Lancet Commission’s planetary health diet framework, processed plant-based products are best treated as convenience foods alongside whole-food proteins such as beans, lentils, tofu and tempeh, not as a replacement for them.
For more plant-based meat options beyond chicken — burgers, deli slices and bacon — see our full guide to the best vegan meat alternatives. If you mainly want extra protein, our best vegan protein powder roundup covers that side.
Frequently asked questions
Is No Evil Foods Comrade Cluck discontinued?
Yes. No Evil Foods stopped production and closed, so Comrade Cluck is no longer made. Any listing you find for it on Amazon will show as unavailable.
What is the closest substitute for Comrade Cluck?
On base ingredient, a wheat-protein seitan such as Upton’s Naturals Traditional Seitan is the closest. For a pantry-friendly option that shreds into chicken-style strips, Butler Soy Curls are the most flexible pick on this list.
Is there a shelf-stable vegan chicken?
Yes. Dried products such as Butler Soy Curls, Creative Pea Chicken Free and Plant Basics Hearty Plant Protein keep in the pantry, and unMEAT Chicken Style Chunks come in cans that are shelf-stable until opened.
Are these alternatives gluten-free?
Some are. Butler Soy Curls, Creative Pea and Plant Basics are listed as gluten-free. Seitan (Upton’s) is made from wheat gluten, and Gardein’s tenders are breaded with grains. Check each listing’s allergen statement before buying.
How we picked
Stay Healthy Vegan does not perform physical product testing or run taste panels. Every product above was chosen from its Amazon listing and manufacturer information, and was in stock on Amazon when this page was updated. Descriptions come from those listings only. See our methodology for how we work.
As an Amazon Associate, Stay Healthy Vegan earns from qualifying purchases. We may earn a commission when you click an affiliate link, at no extra cost to you. See our full disclosure for detail. Editorial picks are independent of affiliate revenue — see /methodology/.